The difference between a HELOC and a home equity loan is how you receive and repay the money. A home equity loan pays one lump sum at closing, usually at a fixed rate, repaid in equal monthly installments. A HELOC is a credit line you draw on as needed, usually at a variable rate, with interest only on what you have borrowed.
Both borrow against your home equity, both put the home at risk if you cannot pay, and, as the CFPB notes, both add a second monthly payment on top of an existing mortgage.
What is the difference between a HELOC and a home equity loan?
| Feature | Home equity loan | HELOC |
|---|---|---|
| How you get the money | One lump sum at closing | Draw as needed up to a limit |
| Interest charged on | The full amount from day one | Only the amount drawn |
| Rate | Usually fixed | Usually variable (index + margin) |
| Payment | Same every month | Changes with balance and rate; often interest-only at first |
| Reuse | No; a new loan is needed for more money | Yes, during the draw period |
| End of term | Paid off by the last installment | Repayment period, sometimes a balloon payment |
| Lender can freeze or cut it | No (the money is already paid out) | Yes, after a significant drop in home value or a material change in finances |
| Right to cancel (principal home) | 3 business days (12 CFR 1026.23) | 3 business days (12 CFR 1026.15) |
| Home at risk | Yes | Yes |
The CFPB's HELOC booklet sums up the trade-off. The home equity loan's advantage is "equal payments that pay off the entire loan"; its drawback is that "if you need more money, you need to apply for a new loan." The HELOC lets you keep borrowing "without additional approvals or paperwork", but the repayment amount varies.
How do the payments compare?
Both use the same arithmetic once money is borrowed. A home equity loan is amortized from the first month:
M = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n), r = APR ÷ 12
A HELOC is often interest-only in the draw period (balance × APR ÷ 12) and amortized afterwards. The mechanics are in how a HELOC works.
Cost of borrowing $50,000 over 15 years, assuming an 8.5% fixed home equity loan and a HELOC at 7.5% (the prime rate of 7.00% in November 2026 plus a 0.5-point margin), with the HELOC repaid on the same 15-year schedule:
| Scenario | Monthly payment | Total interest over 15 years |
|---|---|---|
| Home equity loan, 8.5% fixed | $492.37 | $38,626.56 |
| HELOC, rate stays at 7.5% | $463.51 | $33,431.11 |
| HELOC, +1 point after 2 years | $489.24 from year 3 | $37,444.91 |
| HELOC, +2 points after 2 years | $515.70 from year 3 | $41,572.67 |
| HELOC, +3 points after 2 years | $542.86 from year 3 | $45,810.94 |
The HELOC rows re-amortize the $46,103.03 balance left after 24 months over the remaining 156 months at the new rate. Break-even falls between +1 and +2 points: if the HELOC rate rises by more than about 1.3 points early on and stays there, the fixed loan would have been cheaper. A smaller margin, a fixed-rate conversion option or a rate cap (every home-secured variable-rate loan must state a maximum rate under 12 CFR 1026.30) shifts that line.
The rates are illustrations. HELOCs often start below fixed home equity loans because the borrower carries the rate risk, but the gap varies by lender, credit score and CLTV.
When does a HELOC cost less?
When money goes out in stages. A $50,000 kitchen remodel paid in four $12,500 installments, at the start of months 1, 4, 7 and 10:
- HELOC at 7.5%, interest-only: interest on $12,500 for three months, then $25,000, $37,500 and $50,000 = $2,343.75 in the first year.
- Home equity loan at 8.5%: the full $50,000 is borrowed at closing; the first 12 payments carry $4,183.84 of interest (and also repay $1,724.60 of principal).
The HELOC's lower first-year interest comes from two sources: a lower assumed rate and interest only on money actually spent. The HELOC borrower has also repaid no principal, so the comparison only holds if the draw period is used deliberately.
HELOCs also suit an emergency reserve (no interest until used, though some plans charge annual or inactivity fees) and projects whose final cost is unknown.
When is a home equity loan the better fit?
- One known expense, paid at once, such as consolidating a set amount of debt or a fixed contractor price.
- Budget certainty matters more than the lowest starting rate. The payment never changes and the loan ends on a fixed date.
- Avoiding payment shock. There is no switch from interest-only to amortizing payments and no balloon.
- Avoiding a freeze. A HELOC agreement may let the lender stop new draws or cut the limit if the home's value falls significantly (12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)); money from a home equity loan is already in hand.
What do the two have in common?
- Collateral and limits. Lenders size both by the combined loan-to-value: home value × maximum CLTV minus the mortgage balance.
- Approval. Credit, income and the debt-to-income ratio matter for both; the DTI calculator shows where you stand.
- Closing costs. Appraisal, application, title and recording fees can apply to both; some lenders waive them, and some HELOCs carry an early termination fee instead. The CFPB booklet includes a three-offer checklist for comparing these.
- Tax treatment. IRS Publication 936 (2025 returns) makes the interest on either deductible only when the money is used to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures it, you itemize, and total home debt is within $750,000 ($375,000 married filing separately).
- Payoff on sale. Both generally have to be repaid when the home is sold.
Worked example: choosing for a $30,000 project
A borrower needs $30,000 for a roof replacement billed at completion and wants it paid off in 10 years. Offers: a home equity loan at 8.5% fixed, or a HELOC at 7.5% variable.
- Home equity loan: $30,000 at 8.5% over 120 months = $371.96 a month, $14,634.85 total interest, fixed.
- HELOC repaid over the same 10 years at a constant 7.5% = $356.11 a month, $12,732.64 total interest.
- Difference: $15.85 a month and $1,902.21 over 10 years in the HELOC's favor if the rate never moves.
Because the whole amount is spent at once, the HELOC's draw-as-needed advantage does not apply. The choice comes down to whether a saving of about $16 a month is worth carrying the rate risk.
How to compare offers
- Get at least three quotes for each product and compare the APR, not just the rate.
- For HELOCs, ask for the index, the margin, how often the rate adjusts, the lifetime cap and floor, any teaser period, the draw and repayment lengths, and whether a balloon payment applies.
- List every fee: appraisal, application, closing, annual, inactivity, transaction and early termination.
- Check the payment at a rate 2–3 points higher than today's, as in the table above.
- Remember the right to cancel within three business days after closing if the loan is secured by your principal home.
For a debt-consolidation plan, compare the result with paying cards down directly; debt snowball vs avalanche shows that path without putting the home on the line.
Educational information only, not financial, tax or legal advice. Rates in the examples are illustrations, not offers.